Court overturned the refusal to hear a challenge to apartment association decisions
Editorial summary
Apartment owners appealed the refusal to take up their application challenging the association’s decisions and seeking a substitute board member.
Narva linn, Energia tn 3 korteriühistu
Participants and roles
- Applicants and appellants – five apartment owners XX
- Interested party – Narva linn, Energia tn 3 korteriühistu
The dispute and the court’s decision
Five apartment owners challenged decisions adopted by written vote on 21 May 2021 on the management plan, repairs, the annual report and earmarked contributions. They argued that the voting period was too short and that the documents had shortcomings. They also sought the appointment of a substitute board member. Viru Maakohus refused to take up the application because it considered it legally unviable, citing in particular the lack of information about recorded objections.
Tartu Ringkonnakohus distinguished between two claims. An association member who took part in adopting a decision can ask the court to set it aside if their objection was recorded in the minutes. Any member may seek a declaration that the decision was void from the outset, regardless of whether they took part in the vote. When assessing whether an application is legally viable, the court proceeds on the facts alleged and does not weigh the evidence. The applicants should have been told what to clarify and given time to do so. The owners had already asked the court to obtain the voting minutes and ballot forms from the association.
The lower court should also have given the owners a chance to clarify their request for a substitute board member. The alleged shortcomings of the management plan and annual report were insufficient on their own to justify an appointment.
Outcome of this decision
Tartu Ringkonnakohus partially upheld the appeal. It set aside the refusal to take up the application and the order requiring the applicants to bear the costs. Viru Maakohus must give the owners time to correct the application and decide again whether to take it up. The refusal to grant interim relief had become final. The database does not yet record whether the application was taken up after it was sent back or how the dispute ended.