Skip to decisions
Žuk — ANTON и JELENA
Back to decisions

Court sent the roof repair payment dispute back for rehearing

Editorial summary

The contractor sought payment for roof repairs. The apartment association claimed damages, citing leaks and defects in the work.

Judgment · Tartu Ringkonnakohus · Appeal

Narva linn, Uusküla tn 6 korteriühistu

Repairs and shared propertyRoof and atticDamage and insuranceLeaks and floodingDamage caused during repairsCause and proof of damageAmount of compensationContracts and servicesWorks contracts and designQuality and acceptance of worksPayment, advance payments and refunds
Participants and roles
  • Claimant, counterclaim defendant and appellant – MIRSTART OÜ
  • Defendant and counterclaimant – Narva linn, Uusküla tn 6 korteriühistu

The dispute and the court’s decision

MIRSTART OÜ claimed the outstanding payment of €19,120.90. It maintained that it had completed the work and corrected the defects, and that the association had no grounds to refuse to sign the acceptance report. The association cited leaks and serious defects and counterclaimed for €43,105.80. Viru Maakohus dismissed the contractor’s claim and granted the association’s counterclaim. Tartu Ringkonnakohus found that the lower court had left important facts unresolved and that its reasoning was contradictory. The lower court must determine what the parties agreed to, whether they changed the scope of the work and whether the contract ended. The legal basis on which it ended affects whether the contractor can claim the agreed payment or compensation for the value of the work. The association must substantiate its damages claim in light of the contractor’s objections. The court also pointed to the possibility of setting off the parties’ claims against each other. The lower court had failed to assess the final report relied on by the contractor and had given insufficient reasons for declining to order an expert assessment. The association’s audit did not establish the scope of the contracted work, the repairs needed or their approximate cost. On rehearing, the lower court must reconsider whether an expert assessment is needed.

Outcome of this decision

Tartu Ringkonnakohus partially upheld the contractor’s appeal, set aside the judgment of 19 November 2021 in full and sent the case back to Viru Maakohus for rehearing from the preliminary stage. The lower court must reconsider both claims and allocate costs in its final ruling. The database does not yet contain a ruling recording the outcome of the rehearing.

Entry into force has not been reverified