Did an invoice entry create a duty to pay for a defect or its concealment?
Editorial summary
Four claimants asked the court to declare that they owed the association nothing for a defect or its concealment. Korteriühistu Nartall 18 admitted the claim and explained that the disputed entries on the invoice were for information only.
Narva linn, Tallinna mnt 18 korteriühistu
Participants and roles
- Claimants – four individuals XX.
- Defendant – Korteriühistu Nartall 18 (Narva linn, Tallinna mnt 18 korteriühistu).
The dispute and the court’s decision
The entries appeared on an invoice dated 5 July 2011 and referred to a general meeting resolution of 30 April. Three claimants were billed for a defect and the fourth for concealing it. At the hearing, the association confirmed that the sums were not payable. The court granted the claim on that admission, without determining whether there was a defect or who might have been responsible.
Outcome of this decision
The court declared that none of the four claimants had to pay the disputed charges. The association had to reimburse the claimants’ litigation costs, bear its own costs and pay the state the portion of the filing fee previously waived for one claimant. The judgment was immediately enforceable.