Skip to decisions
Žuk — ANTON и JELENA
Back to decisions

Kangelaste 3: dispute over nullity of a meeting decision ended after waiver of the claim

Viru Maakohus · First instance

Apartment association meetings and decisions

Kangelaste 3: dispute over nullity of a meeting decision ended after waiver of the claim

Ruling · Viru Maakohus · First instance

OÜ Rosehill · Korteriühistu Kangelaste 3 · 10972543 · 80162521

Entry into force has not been reverified

Participants and roles: Claimant – OÜ Rosehill; Defendant – Korteriühistu Kangelaste 3

How it started · editorial summary

The company waived its demand for a declaration that part of the meeting decision was void; the court concluded the case.

The dispute and the court’s decision

The court terminated OÜ Rosehill’s case against Korteriühistu Kangelaste 3 after the company waived its demand. The company had sought a declaration of partial nullity of the general meeting decision of 4 October 2017, meaning no legal effect for the challenged part from adoption. On 11 September 2018, the claimant applied to end the case and requested reimbursement of half the court fee. The association agreed to termination. The court accepted the waiver and ordered a refund to the company of 150 euros out of the 300-euro fee paid. This ruling does not disclose the substance of the challenged part or why the demand was waived. It did not establish nullity of the meeting decision. The court explained a different consequence of accepting the waiver: the same claimant cannot bring the same claim against the same defendant on the same grounds again.

Outcome of this decision

Accept the waiver and terminate proceedings. Order a court fee refund of 150 euros to OÜ Rosehill.
Translation of an anonymised, abridged excerpt from Estonian
1. Terminate proceedings on the claim by OÜ Rosehill against Korteriühistu Kangelaste 3 […]