Skip to decisions
Žuk — ANTON и JELENA
Back to decisions

Reasons added to the company’s debt judgment

Editorial summary

The court added description and reasons to the earlier judgment between the association and OÜ Antek Ehitus. The award of 1557.99 euros in debt, 836.30 euros in interest and capped further interest remained in place.

Judgment supplemented with description and reasons · Viru Maakohus · First instance

Narva linn, A. Puškini tn 15 korteriühistu · 80128553

OÜ Antek Ehitus · 12027984

Apartment association bills, payments and debtsDebt claimsBills and justification of chargesLate-payment interest and consequences of delayHeatingCalculation and allocation of heating chargesWater and sewerageCalculation of water chargesPayment accounting and set-off
Participants and roles
  • Claimant — Narva linn, A. Puškini tn 15 korteriühistu
  • Defendant and premises owner — OÜ Antek Ehitus

The dispute and the court’s decision

Narva linn, A. Puškini tn 15 korteriühistu, named in the source as KÜ Puškini 15, sought management and utility charges from OÜ Antek Ehitus, including debt predating the company’s acquisition of the premises. The company disputed proof and calculation of the debt, receipt of bills, the basis of interest and credit for a payment it claimed to have made. After the judgment of 17 March 2014, a participant notified the court of an intended appeal. This decision adds description and reasons to that judgment; it does not award the same debt twice. The court found the calculation proved, delivery to the known mailbox sufficient for access to bills, and the claimed payment unproved. It also accepted the acquirer’s liability for earlier arrears and the claimed interest rate. The supplemented judgment retains principal of 1557.99 euros and accrued interest of 836.30 euros. Future interest is 0.07% per day on unpaid principal until payment, capped at the principal amount. Each side bears its own costs; the judgment is immediately enforceable without security. A subsequent appeal, entry into force and actual payment have not been reverified.

Outcome of this decision

Description and reasons were added to the earlier judgment. The award remains 1557.99 euros in debt, 836.30 euros in interest and future interest of 0.07% per day on unpaid principal, capped at the principal amount. Each side bears its costs; the same debt is not awarded again.

Entry into force has not been reverified

Case history