Skip to decisions
Žuk — ANTON и JELENA
Back to decisions

Sharing cold-water losses by number of residents: a dispute over the vote

Editorial summary

Three members of KORTERIÜHISTU Kerese 36 challenged a resolution passed on 6 December 2009. It allocated an extra charge for cold-water losses according to the number of people living in each apartment. The court considered who could register participants and how many votes the city could cast as the owner of several apartments.

Judgment · Viru Maakohus · First instance

Narva linn, P. Kerese tn 36 korteriühistu

Water and sewerageAllocation of water consumption and discrepanciesCalculation of water chargesApartment association meetings and decisionsConvening meetings and advance noticeQuorum and repeat meetingsVoting and representationAgenda and minutesBudget, management plan and rates
Participants and roles
  • Three claimants – members of the association
  • Defendant – KORTERIÜHISTU Kerese 36 (Narva linn, P. Kerese tn 36 korteriühistu)

The dispute and the court’s decision

After the November meeting failed to reach a quorum, a group of members called a repeat meeting. The board took over registration without the organisers’ consent. The court considered it important that participants signed to confirm their attendance. Calling the meeting and setting its agenda did not give the organisers the exclusive right to register participants or open the meeting. The court accepted that the city had one vote for each apartment it owned. The minutes showed that the proposal to abolish the charge was put to a vote and that the majority backed the existing arrangement. The court also rejected the association’s argument that a meeting on 7 June 2010 had confirmed the December resolution. The June agenda called for a fresh decision on allocating water losses.

Outcome of this decision

The court dismissed the challenge to the December resolution, finding no irregularity in calling the meeting or adopting the resolution. The claimants withdrew their separate challenges to the resolutions of 11 May 2009 concerning the cold-water charge and the 2009 management plan. The court closed that part of the proceedings and ordered the claimants to bear the costs.

Entry into force has not been reverified