Skip to decisions
Žuk — ANTON и JELENA
Back to decisions

Why the court declined to hear an association employee’s reinstatement claim

Editorial summary

An employee sought reinstatement with KÜ Gerassimovi. Before the employee went to court, the labour dispute committee had granted in full the request for a declaration that the termination of the employment contract was void.

Court order · Viru Maakohus · First instance

Narva linn, V. Gerassimovi tn 18 korteriühistu

The apartment association as employerTermination of employment contracts
Participants and roles
  • Claimant – employee XX.
  • Defendant – employer KÜ Gerassimovi (Narva linn, V. Gerassimovi tn 18 korteriühistu).

The dispute and the court’s decision

The committee found the employer’s extraordinary termination of the contract void, then ended the contract by its own decision and awarded the employee compensation. The court explained that the employee could bring before it only the part of the original claim that the committee had rejected. There was no such part. Reinstatement was also a different remedy from the declaration sought before the committee. Referring to the committee’s hearing record, the court noted that the employer had opposed continuing the employment relationship.

Outcome of this decision

The court declined to admit the claim and ordered the application and its attachments returned to the employee. It left the employee to bear the litigation costs. It did not decide the merits of reinstatement.

Entry into force has not been reverified